Embracing Change: The Courage to Rewrite/Self edit Your Novel Based on Feedback
- teganfairleywrites
- Oct 27
- 3 min read
Writing a novel can be an exciting adventure, but it also comes with its challenges. After spending countless months crafting and polishing my manuscript, I faced the essential step of seeking feedback. Although the idea of making significant changes felt intimidating, I discovered that embracing this process was not just necessary – it was rewarding. In this post, I will share my experiences and insights on finding the courage to rewrite your novel in response to feedback.
The Initial Fear of Feedback and Edits
When I first shared my work with beta readers and critique partners, I felt a mix of excitement and anxiety. Their perspectives were crucial for my growth, but there was always the dreaded chance that my beloved characters or plot ideas missed the mark. One particular instance stands out. After distributing my draft, I received a detailed critique that pointed out my protagonist's inconsistent motivations. Initially, it felt like a punch to the gut, sparking a defensive attitude within me. Why didn’t they understand my vision? Yet, taking a step back, I soon realised this feedback was an invaluable opportunity to assess my work more objectively.
Studies show that authors who actively seek and incorporate feedback often see a significant improvement in their writing. A survey conducted by the Editorial Freelancers Association found that 70% of writers who engage in critique groups report higher satisfaction with their final manuscript. This statistic made it clear that feedback is a gift meant to enhance, not diminish, our stories.
The Humbling Experience of Deleting
One of the toughest parts of rewriting is the act of deletion. It often feels like saying goodbye to a part of oneself. I had to remind myself that a well-loved scene or character may not always serve the story's overall purpose. (Besides, all deleted scenes are sitting in a graveyard document on my drive so they're still around).
For example, I had crafted a subplot featuring an intriguing character that I thought added depth. However, after thoughtful feedback, it became clear that this subplot confused readers and detracted from the main narrative. What I once considered my best work was holding the story back. The act of deleting was painful, but necessary. I learned that sometimes simplicity leads to stronger storytelling.
The Power of Rewriting
Once I decided to remove certain elements, I discovered a new freedom in my writing. Rewriting opened doors to explore fresh ideas and new directions for my plot.
Instead of feeling daunted by a blank page, I approached it as an opportunity for creativity. I experimented with my protagonist's journey, enhancing the emotional stakes. As a result, I transformed my story from a simple adventure into a deeper exploration of loss and recovery. The rewriting process not only improved my manuscript but also rekindled my passion for storytelling.
Embracing Constructive Criticism
Receiving feedback remains a humbling experience, but I learned to approach it with an open mind. It was essential to distinguish between constructive criticism and mere opinions. Not every suggestion fits, and that's perfectly okay.
Over time, I began viewing feedback as a valuable tool for growth. This shift made it easier to embrace the necessary changes without feeling personally attacked. For instance, when a reader pointed out a pacing issue in my narrative, I could take the criticism in stride. This change in mindset allowed me to improve the flow and clarity of my story significantly.
The Rewarding Outcome
After months of hard work and reflection, I felt a profound sense of accomplishment. My story is evolving into something I am genuinely be proud of. The journey of rewriting transformed my draft into a stronger narrative.
Not only am I improving my manuscript, but I also gained deeper insights into my characters and themes. The feedback that once felt unnerving became a key driver of my progress. This transformation taught me that welcoming change is crucial to the writing process.

Finding Your Support System
One of the essential lessons I’ve learned is the power of a supportive writing community. Sharing my work with those who understand the challenges has been incredibly valuable.
Engagement in writing groups, workshops, or online forums can provide crucial support. . Finding a network that encourages honest critique fosters accountability and growth in our writing experiences.
Embracing the Journey Ahead
As writers, we must embrace change and recognize feedback as a powerful resource for improvement. By doing so, we enhance not only our manuscripts but also our confidence and resilience as writers.
So the next time feedback strikes you as overwhelming, take a deep breath. Seize the chance to evolve your story. Each rewrite brings you closer to the novel you have always envisioned. Let's celebrate the writing journey together, where every revision symbolizes our progress as authors.



Comments